According to the Law Commission, the current law does not “provide a cohesive framework in which parties to a divorce or dissolution can expect fair and sufficiently certain outcomes.” The reason for this is the wide-ranging discretion contained in the current law, which allows judges significant scope for interpreting the statutes.
Before examining the proposals in the review, this blog will consider the current law governing financial considerations in divorce.
Current provisions for financial settlements in divorce
Financial settlements in divorce are based on the principle that there should be a fair division. The law establishing this is contained in the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 (the “Act”). Whilst the provisions indicate that they should be fair, that does not mean there must be a 50/50 split.
Section 25 of the Act introduces many matters to which the court must have regard when exercising its powers in relation to matrimonial financial settlements upon divorce. The court must consider:
- Each party’s income, earning capacity, property and other financial resources. The judge will consider each party’s resources now and for the foreseeable future.
- The financial needs, obligations and responsibilities of each party.
- The standard of living the family enjoyed during the marriage.
- The parties’ ages and how long they were married.
- Whether either party had a physical or mental disability.
- What contribution each party has made or is likely to make to the family’s welfare in the foreseeable future. This includes looking after the home or caring for the family.
- How each party has conducted themselves. This applies if the conduct is such that, in the court’s opinion, it would be inequitable to ignore it.
- The value of each party to any benefit they will lose due to the divorce.
Further provisions in relation to children:
The court must consider the financial needs of the children of the family in resolving matrimonial financial matters. The first consideration of the court is for children of the family under the age of 18 years.
The court should consider:
- The financial needs of the child.
- The child’s financial resources, including any income, earning capacity and property.
- If the child has a physical or mental disability.
- The child’s education: current and expected education requirements.
- Any of the considerations discussed above between the parties in so far as they relate to the child.
And, in respect of children who are not children of one of the parties:
- Whether the party who is not the natural parent assumed any responsibility, the basis on which that was done and what, if anything, they contributed to the child’s maintenance and how that contribution went on, and
- Whether they did that in the knowledge the child was not their own, and
- The liability of any other person to maintain that child.
When the court weighs these wide-ranging provisions, it might conclude in the interests of fairness that an unequal split of assets on divorce should favour one of the parties.
The Civil Partnership Act 2004 contains provisions that mirror those in the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 and apply to the dissolution of a civil partnership.
The Law Commission and financial considerations in divorce:
The Law Commission has conducted a detailed review of the law. It has concluded that “it is not possible for an individual going through a divorce to understand, by reading statute, how their case will be decided. The law lacks certainty and accessibility to an extent that could be argued is inconsistent with the rule of law.” In other words, the Law Commission believes this area of law badly needs remediation and consolidation.
On 18 December 2024, the Law Commission published a Scoping Report. This is a detailed report, and it discusses four possible models for reforming the law:
- Codify the existing law.
- Codify the law and provide statutory reform on discrete issues (for example, pre-nuptial agreements).
- Introduce a set of underpinning principles and objectives to guide the court’s discretion.
- Create a ‘matrimonial property regime’ that will provide rules for dividing up property on divorce, with the court’s discretion strictly confined.
The Commission believes it is essential to introduce a degree of certainty into divorce proceedings regarding financial matters.
To discuss this, or any other related matter with Andrea directly, please call 01483 887766, email info@hartbrown.co.uk or start a live chat today.
*This is not legal advice; it is intended to provide information of general interest about current legal issues.
